Skip to main content

Individual vs. Group Disobedience

Individual disobedience is fully committing to fight for a cause you believe in. As Henry David Thoreau states, it is casting "your whole vote, not a strip of paper merely, but your whole influence." On the other hand, group disobedience requires the commitment of multiple individuals - the more the better. So can individual disobedience be effective? 







In some cases, probably not. If I decided it was unjust for me to write this post, I could follow in the footsteps of Thoreau and refuse to do it. However, that would simply result in a zero, and likely no change would be made. If I continued this behavior for the year, I would fail the class, and still, no change would be made. In this case, individual disobedience is ineffective.

However, in other cases, such as the one of Jaswant Singh Khalra, individual disobedience was greatly impactful. Jaswant Singh Khalra was a human rights activist from Punjab, India, who devoted his life to uncovering the truth behind the thousands of people who went missing during the government’s long-standing conflict with the Sikhs in the 1980s and 1990s. He became aware of the disappearances of thousands of Sikhs when he noticed a sudden drop in the Sikh population in his home district of Tarn Taran. He began to investigate the issue and soon discovered that the Indian government was carrying out a covert operation called "Operation Woodrose" in which thousands of Sikhs were illegally detained, tortured, and murdered by the police and security forces. Khalra tirelessly worked against the government to expose these atrocities and traveled across India to collect evidence and testimonies from the families of the missing people. Through his efforts, he singlehandedly uncovered over 25,000 killings, suggesting that individual disobedience can be effective in some situations. 









Therefore, I think that disobedience can have an impact either at the group level or individual level. However, if the argument against a policy or action is not well-founded or based on ethical principles, it can be highly ineffective. Nonetheless, if you are passionate about something, put your all into it "for it matters not how small the beginning may seem to be: what is once well done is done forever."

Comments

  1. Divya DwarakanathSeptember 24, 2023 at 3:37 PM

    I find it really cool how you connected this extremely important piece of history which can be considered almost unknown and tied it to a bigger picture. I thought it made your point even more effective!

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousSeptember 25, 2023 at 6:21 AM

    I like how you connected the civil disobedience piece to a human rights activist in India

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

attempting to plan out my life

I can't lie - I don't know how likely I am to really come back to this list. Regardless, here are the books I hope I read in the next ten years: 2026 - The Autobiography of Malcolm X by Malcolm X and Alex Haley I'll be honest - my dad has been begging me to read this for the last few years, and I think it's finally time I listen. This will be my first year of college, meaning it's time to really get educated beyond just the subdued version of history I am exposed to at school. Especially because I will be spending so much time in Detroit during my freshman year, I think it is imperative that I learn about black history and its ties to the city. 2027 - American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins I've heard a lot about the life-changing nature of this novel, and by 2027, I truly think this issue will be a prominent focus in American politics, culture, and society. When I was a freshman, I vaguely remember listening to a podcast episode featuring Cummins during a long drive,...
Post a Comment
Read more

race plays a role

Elham: "They like English accent French accent not your accent not my accent" This line stuck with me as I read the play, especially when you mentioned your inability to relate to it because you are two generations deep, almost fully assimilated into "American" culture. I am also 2 generations deep, a second-generation American. So why is my experience different? It's because: - The sub spells my name when calling attendance instead of attempting to say it. - My first-grade teacher refused to believe I celebrated Thanksgiving. - No history textbook has a picture of someone like me. It's because I've had the following conversation more times than I can count: Them: "Where are you from?" Me: I live in Michigan, I'm American. Them: "No, where are you really from?" And as much as I feel the urge to respond passive-aggressively, I’ve come to realize that these questions often come from kind, well-meaning people who are simply curious. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

My Story

I'm an overthinker. I'm an overthinker to a level you can't even imagine. Every minute left on delivered, every slight change in tone, and every period in a text message means something to me. I'm constantly asking myself: Are they mad at me? What did I do wrong? How do I even begin replying to this? Amidst this constant anxiety, I do my best to remind myself to be present, put my phone down, and worry less about the outcome. And yet, this often causes further tension: Am I living in the moment enough? Am I missing something important? Am I doing this all wrong? The poem A Story by Li-Young Lee resonated with me because of this constant internal conflict. Throughout the poem, the father, so focused on the possibility of the son's future, cannot express his feelings of love in the moment.  With just one more quarter of the life I have known for the past thirteen years left, I find myself caught in the same trap. I worry when I enjoy something so much that I lose tra...
Post a Comment
Read more