Skip to main content

Mount Rushmore: Graffiti or Monument?

Mount Rushmore National Monument is situated in South Dakota's Black Hills. This impressive carving contains the faces of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, and Abraham Lincoln. Many argue that Mount Rushmore is necessary, as it is an important tribute to individuals who have contributed to "the founding, expansion, preservation, and unification of the United States" (Borglum). In addition, Mount Rushmore symbolizes freedom and democracy while also representing both the past and the future. 









However, the history of the monument has led to controversy over the years. It was built on stolen land, taken from the Lakota Sioux, leading to many present-day protests that bring attention to the history of Indigenous displacement. In 2020, Indigenous groups protested at Donald Trump's speech at the Mount Rushmore, chanting "Land Back" as a passionate expression of their demands. Many asserted that the monument is like graffiti on their cherished land.










The stolen land isn't the only controversy surrounding the history of Mount Rushmore. The monument was sculpted by Gutzon Borglum, a man with an association with the Ku Klux Klan (KKK). The KKK not only impacted the black community but also used tactics of intimidation and violence to drive away Indigenous tribes. 

Finally, the monument is carved in an effort to memorialize 4 influential presidents of the past. They are portrayed in honorable and powerful ways, indicating that they were respected figures who left a lasting legacy of influence and impact. However, people are now uncovering the many controversial aspects of each man's history, arguing that they should not be commemorated.

In my opinion, the landmark should be handed back over to the people who inhabited the area many years ago because it is essential to acknowledge that the land was taken from the Lakota Sioux without their consent. Returning this sacred land to its rightful owners would be a powerful step toward reconciliation and justice, as it recognizes the historical injustices faced by Indigenous people. At the end of the day, it is their right to determine the future of the monument.

Comments

  1. Arya ShahSeptember 9, 2023 at 9:37 PM

    This post was very informative. I had no idea that the monument was constructed by a man with an association with the KKK. Reading this has made me much more aware to question the things that are often glorified.

    ReplyDelete
  2. HemnaSeptember 10, 2023 at 12:00 PM

    I was aware of the controversy behind this monument like the protests but had no idea about its ties to the KKK. I also wish the landmark could be given back to the Lakota Sioux and people would be more understanding of why this is important. Pushing towards progress means making difficult choices even if that means giving up things that are treasured.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Best Sapphic Artists (in my professional opinion)

Since we read "The Three Girls" this week, a very queer-coded piece, I made a list of my favorite sapphic artists: 5) Chappell Roan It seems impossible to compile a list of sapphic artists without including Chappell Roan. After her viral Coachella performance in April this year and her subsequent release of "Good Luck, Babe!" Chappell seems to have come out of nowhere. She is known for her love of drag and won Best New Artist at the VMAs. In some ways, she reminds me of the Marilyn Monroe we studied in "The Three Girls," especially in her desire to escape fame in some moments. However, she is also the opposite, incredibly vocal about her queer identity in every aspect of her life. I can't list her as my favorite, simply because I have not listened to her music enough, especially because she is so new to the spotlight. However, I absolutely love her unapologetic nature and can't wait to see what she does next! 4) LYVIA LYVIA is definitely the smalle...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Average High School Experience (...right?)

My eyes dilated at the paper in front of me. I tried to control my breathing as I felt myself hyper-focusing on the crinkle at the top of the page. This is an imminent disaster. Why did I let him pass the paper to me? I should’ve just gotten it myself. There’s something so beautiful about a flat, perfect sheet of paper - why would anyone want to ruin it? Honestly, the assignment is barely worth doing if the paper is wrinkled. I attempt to refocus on the teacher’s lecture (something about poetry?) but there’s no use. The crease controls me.
Post a Comment
Read more

Make Sleeping Cool Again

I still can't begin to understand how people manage to function off of 2-3 hours of sleep every night. And yet, everyone seems to be doing it? There's no doubt that we've turned it into some crazy competition. I'm already prepared to walk in tomorrow and hear the following conversation: "oh my godddddd. i literally stayed up until midnight to finish that blog post." "that means you basically got 6 hours of sleep. ugh you're so luckyyyyy. i stayed up till 3." So, not only are we invalidating others' problems, but we are also creating a culture that encourages others to make unhealthy choices for bragging rights. It's not the only thing we do it for either: "you wrote your ap seminar paper three days before it was due? i did mine the literal day it was due." "i can't believe you drive 50 in a 45. like you gotta drive 65 at least!" This isn't to say that I'm not guilty of the exact same things, but I'm sta...
Post a Comment
Read more